The Best Oven Mitts for The Discerning Cook

No kitchen is complete without oven mitts. In fact, you’d have a hard time looking for a serious cook or chef that does not own one or two. Oven mitts are, undoubtedly, a must have in any home.

Hence, for something as essential and frequently used as your oven or your pots and pans, you will need the best oven mitts. There are a lot of oven mitts and gloves out there. But a discerning cook will know the best from the rest.

Hence, we’re here to help you out in this regard, so you’ll know what exactly makes a great oven mitt. For instance, not only should these mitts effectively protect your hands but they should also be strong enough to last while looking great at the same time.​

We say “oven mitts that look great” because people often overlook the design (and even maintenance) of their mitts, preferring only to look at its effectivity.

While good-looking oven mitts may not be at the top of your list, be assured that your mitts don’t have to look like they come from a coal factory. You can have efficient and quality mitts that look great too!​

More...

Let’s start with a quick look at the top 5 best oven mitts.

*Below, you can read more our detailed reviews for each above Oven Mitts.

The Cook’s Gauntlets: Buyer’s Guide

Gloves and Mittens

best oven mitts

Obviously, you would use oven mitts to protect your hands from the heat as you handle food and equipment in and out of an oven. These gloves can often also be used with cast-iron pans and pots and other culinary applications where high temperatures are involved.

The concept of wearing gloves or mittens to protect the hands against heat, whether for cooking or for work that involved high temperatures, goes back centuries. It is not precisely known, though, when an insulated glove was first used in cooking.

However, like many a kitchen tool, the oven mitt was a product of necessity. Since then, the oven mitt has kept many hands, and fingers, safe.

Are Oven Mitts Essential ?

best oven mitts 4

Via ebay.com

Yes, they are ! It doesn’t matter if it’s a private or commercial kitchen. Because they keep your hands safe as well as promote safety in the kitchen, oven mitts are a necessity !

​This is rightly so whether you’re an occasional amateur cook, a master baker, a mother of five, or a 3-michelin star chef.

Cooking can be completely fulfilling but to maintain that joy would require some degree of safety, and responsibility. The happiness of fast cooking turns into anger and frustration when pain, especially in the form of burns and singes, comes in.

So, to keep things fun and happy in your kitchen, you’ll need the best oven mitts to protect you from those nasty burns and annoying splatters !

There are, however, so many choices out there that looking for a good pair of oven mitts can be as frustrating as accidentally touching a hot grill, most especially when you end up purchasing an inferior product.

Not to worry, though, in addition to our top five oven mitts, we’ve also included in the next section the important things you’ll need to check and consider before getting your next oven mitts.​

What Qualities to Look For

1. Material

best oven mitts 3

The material making up the oven mitt is the most crucial element as you make your decision. Remember that the oven mitt’s material will determine its heat resistance, durability, weight, and how easy it is to keep clean.

All oven mitts have some form of thermal insulation and vary in thickness. Products are either made of machine-washable textiles or more durable synthetic materials.

Some oven mitts are even made of Kevlar, the very material that makes up bullet-proof vests. However, the most conventional oven mitt materials are cotton fabrics and silicone.

Each of these two materials has their inherent strengths and weakness which we’ll be discussing as we look at the upcoming sections.​

Heat Resistance

baking homemade oatmea cookies with oven mitts

Oven mitts made up of cotton fabrics, on average, can protect you against temperatures up to 200°F (or 93°C). On the other hand, silicone oven mitts are strong enough to protect your hands from temperatures up to 500°F (or 200°F).

Weight & Durability

Silicon gloves will typically last much longer than cotton fabrics especially since cotton oven mitts tend to thin out when regularly exposed to high heat or regular machine-washing.

Cotton oven mitts, however, will be much lighter than their silicone counterparts. Ultimately, though, the weight between silicone and oven mitts are often negligible, especially with the many advantages that silicone provides.

Easy to Clean

best oven mitts easy to clean

As you prepare, and cook, and bake, it’s only a matter of time until those oven mitts will stain and become dirty. Sauces, dips, oil splatters and other residue means your oven gloves will eventually need washing.

Silicone gloves clearly have the advantage here as they are much easier to rinse and wipe clean while cotton fabrics will absorb fluids and colors and even odors.

Additionally, despite being machine washable, regularly washing cotton oven mitts will hasten their wear and tear.

Versatility

best oven mitts versatility

The best oven mitts will not limit their use to just ovens. Rather, they’ll continue to be useful when handling hot cast-iron pans and pots, holding roasted meat, and also cooking and handling meat on a grill or over an open fire.

These multi-tasking features can only refer to silicone oven mitts since cotton fabrics are only ideal for handling cooking equipment over relatively lower temperatures.

2. Aesthetics

The overall design of the oven mitt includes its exterior and interior features, as well as its size and shape. The majority of these features accentuate both the mitt’s form and its functionality.

Grip

best oven mitts aesthetics

On the exterior of oven mitts, typical of the best ones, are specialized raised treads or dots that helps with grip and control. These features are most commonly on silicone oven mitts that are dotted all over with these treads.

A sure-grip is most noteworthy on particularly slippery surfaces such as glass, non-stick equipment, and ceramics, especially when food or cooking oils unintentionally lubricate these surfaces.

Size

best oven mitts 5

Via bedbathandbeyond.com

Oven mitts come either in one-size-fits-all or the typical small-medium-large. It would be best, for both safety and comfort, that you choose the oven mitt that will fit you as snugly as possible.

Hence, take into account the size and measurements of the product before purchase.

Shape

best oven mitts shape

Although the names “oven mitts” and “oven gloves” are used interchangeably, in their shape is usually where you’ll see their main difference.

Oven gloves often cover your hand and your individual fingers, which allows for more control and dexterity. Meanwhile, oven mitts cover the entire hand except for your thumb, which provides more heat protection, but less fine control.

Comfort

best oven mitts 7

Via wayfair.com

In addition to an oven mitt’s size and shape, its interior features (such as lining or padding) determines how comfortable it will be on your hand.

As mentioned already, many oven mitts feature some form of interior lining or padding, typically made of fabric. These features also add to the oven mitt’s heat resistance.​

Reviews of the 5 Best Oven Mitts

Now, with above information, let’s look into 5 best oven mitts for the discerning cook !

Product

Price

Our Rating

Homwe Professional Silicone Oven Mitt - 1 Pair - Extra Long Oven Mitts with Quilted Liner for Extra Protection - Red

1. Homwe Professional Silicone Oven Mitt - 1 Pair - Extra Long Oven Mitts with Quilted Liner for Extra Protection - Red

$

Silicone Oven Mitts, 1 Pair (2 x Dark Red Mitt), Deluxe Quilted Liner, Bonus Brush

2. Silicone Oven Mitts, 1 Pair (2 x Dark Red Mitt), Deluxe Quilted Liner, Bonus Brush

$

Fred Bear Hands Oven Mitts, Set of 2

3. Fred Bear Hands Oven Mitts, Set of 2

$

Black Silicone Oven Mitts - 1 Pair of Extra Long Professional Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Oven Mitt Set of 2

4. Black Silicone Oven Mitts - 1 Pair of Extra Long Professional Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Oven Mitt Set of 2

$

Number 1 Chef's Choice - Extra Long Silicone Oven Mitts With Trivet - Quilted Cotton Lined Silicone Kitchen Gloves - Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Set of 2 with Silicone Trivet - Elbee 642

5. Number 1 Chef's Choice - Extra Long Silicone Oven Mitts With Trivet - Quilted Cotton Lined Silicone Kitchen Gloves - Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Set of 2 with Bonus Silicone Trivet - Elbee 642

$


1. Homwe Professional Silicone Oven Mitt - 1 Pair - Extra Long Oven Mitts with Quilted Liner for Extra Protection - Red

Silicone Oven Mitts - Commercial Grade, Extra Long Quilted Cotton Lining - Heat Resistant Kitchen Potholder Gloves - 1 Pair (Red) - Homwe

Via Amazon.com

Details:

  • Item Weight: 12 ounces
  • ​14.7 inches long
  • ​Heat resistance to 450°F (232°C)
  • ​Machine Washable

Pros

  • Easy to clean and dishwasher safe.
  • Large area of protection
  • ​Flexible

Cons

  • Needs more grip
  • ​Interior lining may not be dishwasher safe
  • ​These mitts are not recommended for small hands

2. Silicone Oven Mitts, 1 Pair (2 x Dark Red Mitt), Deluxe Quilted Liner, Bonus Brush​

Silicone Oven Mitts, 1 Pair (2 x Dark Red Mitt), Deluxe Quilted Liner, Bonus Brush

Via Amazon.com

Details:

  • Item Weight: 13.6 ounces
  • ​Heat resistance to 450°F (232°C)
  • 11 5/8" long
  • Dishwasher safe

Pros

  • Very comfortable inner lining
  • ​Easy to clean
  • Lightweight
  • Excellent heat resistance
  • Very nice grip

Cons

  • These mitts are not ideal for smaller sized hands
  • ​Protection is limited to hands and wrists
  • Residue collects in the treads

3. Fred Bear Hands Oven Mitts, Set of 2​

Fred Bear Hands Oven Mitts, Set of 2

Via Amazon.com

Details:

  • Made of insulated cotton
  • ​The “paw” pads are made of silicone
  • Item Weight: 8.2 ounces
  • Machine washable

Pros

  • Fits most hand sizes
  • ​Comfortable to use
  • Surprisingly great heat resistance

Cons

  • Bulky
  • ​Although most hands fit nicely, the design of the thumb is quite awkward
  • Easily stains
  • Claws will eventually curl when exposed to heat
  • Uncomfortable grip and maneuverability
  • Not recommended for heavy-duty or oil-centric cooking

4. Black Silicone Oven Mitts - 1 Pair of Extra Long Professional Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Oven Mitt Set of 2​

Black Silicone Oven Mitts - 1 Pair of Extra Long Professional Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Oven Mitt Set of 2

Via Amazon.com

Details:

  • Item Weight: 1 pounds
  • Heat resistance to 482°F (250°C)
  • Non-toxic, food-grade silicone

Pros

  • Protects forearms, as well
  • ​Comfortable to use
  • Soft and flexible material
  • Excellent heat resistance

Cons

  • Relatively heavy
  • ​Maybe too big or bulky for some hands

5. Number 1 Chef's Choice - Extra Long Silicone Oven Mitts With Trivet - Quilted Cotton Lined Silicone Kitchen Gloves - Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Set of 2 with Bonus Silicone Trivet - Elbee 642​

Number 1 Chef's Choice - Extra Long Silicone Oven Mitts With Trivet - Quilted Cotton Lined Silicone Kitchen Gloves - Heat Resistant Potholder Gloves - Set of 2 with Bonus Silicone Trivet - Elbee 642

Via Amazon.com

Details:

  • Item Weight: 8 ounces
  • Heat resistance to 450°F (232°C)
  • Ultra-Flex Silicone
  • Breathable lining

Pros

  • The soft material is perfect for grip and maneuverability
  • ​Comfortable inner lining
  • Easy to clean

Cons

  • Needs more grip
  • ​Large and bulky
  • The more elastic material meant lower heat resistance
  • Not recommended for machine wash

Conclusion

Our favorite is the number (#2) Silicone Oven Mitts, 1 Pair (2 x Dark Red Mitt), Deluxe Quilted Liner, Bonus Brush. These awesome oven mitts were such a joy to use that we were moved to cook and bake more so that we had enough reason to use them !

Silicone Oven Mitts, 1 Pair (2 x Dark Red Mitt), Deluxe Quilted Liner, Bonus Brush

Via Amazon.com

They’re incredibly light and very comfortable to wear while still keeping a good grip on most surfaces. Most of all, though, we hardly felt any heat through the gloves ! Although residue may at a time get stuck on the treads, the gloves are quite easy to clean.

However, the fun and functional Fred Bear Hands Oven Mitts, Set of 2 were a great catch too ! Despite its limited versatility, the bear paw gloves are ideal for families or those who love cooking with kids !

What do you think ? Did we miss a couple of great oven mitts ? Let us know !

0
Shares
Sheila Hutton
 

Hi, I'm Sheila. I love food so much. I learn almost cooking knowledge and recipes from my mother. She has taught me a lot of wonderful dishes. Now, I write all my experience on this website for sharing to you.

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments